your feedback says lacks critical analysis
"Lacks critical analysis"
you have cited 30 papers
you have discussed your methodology
and you're asking yourself
what am I missing
here is exactly what critical writing looks like
and again I'll be using a real example
from climate change and crop research
it's funny that students can spot critical thinking
in other people's writing
but they cannot see that their own writing
is not critical
the simple reason is that description feels analytical
when you are writing it
you know the material you are explaining it carefully
it feels like analysis
but often times it's just description with extra words
let me show you the real difference
using an actual example
let's examine this topic
Topic:
The effect of elevated carbon dioxide on wheat yield under drought stress conditions
The effect of elevated CO2 on wheat yield
under drought stress conditions
I'll show you the same content written at 4 levels
pure description
basic analysis
good analysis
and excellent analysis
now pure description will read like this
"Sam et al., 2018 studied the effect of elevated CO2 on wheat. They found that elevated CO2 increased photosynthesis. Smith and Jones 2019 also studied CO2 effects on crops, they found similar results. Isaiah et al., 2020 conducted experiments in controlled conditions, they measured yield, and found elevated CO2 had positive effects."
what you have just done here is this
you have listed three sources
you have listed what they found
you have evaluated nothing
you have not created a connection between the sources
and you have not told the reader what these things mean you have not analyzed Level 2
basic analysis for the same example
Research consistently demonstrates that elevated CO2 enhance wheat photosynthetic rates and improve water use efficiency under drought conditions (Sam et al., 2018; Smith and Jones 2019; Isaiah et al., 2020). This relationship has important implication for understanding wheat productivity under future climatic change scenarios.
in this one you have synthesized which is nice
you have one interpretive statement
but you have not evaluated evidence quality
you have not acknowledged complexity or contradiction
and the implication is still vague
let me just give you what an excellent analysis will look like
While elevated CO2 consistently improves wheat's water use efficiency and photosynthetic rates under drought stress in controlled conditions (Sam et al., 2018; Smith and Jones 2019; Isaiah et al., 2020), the translation of these benefits to real world agricultural contexts is substantially more complex. Laboratory and growth chamber studies which dominate literature, typically control temperature, isolate CO2 as the only variable, and use well fertilized plants--conditions that rarely reflect the farmer's reality.
now you can continue to build like this
and build like this
state the conditions that people have done the previous research
maybe the temperature that in which they did their research
or the region in which they did their research
find out context
find out the fallibility of those experimental setups
you acknowledge what is known
you identify methodological limitations
you introduce complicating evidence
you draw an original insight from all of that and you generate implications
so take a paragraph that you have written
find the sentence where you say what the source found
now add one sentence however
this finding is limited because you can even add
this suggests that that way
you are making your writing more critical
and that is how you build critical writing
I'll see you in the next one