Hiro and Chris were locked in a serious conversation, both visibly frustrated as they listened back to the sessions. Sitting off to the side, Kim could sense something was wrong and kept pressing for answers, but Hiro brushed him off, clearly focused on figuring out the problem. It didn't take long for Kim to suspect that the issue involved the drums, especially since their drummer Scott wasn't even part of the discussion. When the conversation finally wrapped up, Hiro turned and explained what had happened. The news was worse than expected. The recordings they'd just spent thousands of dollars on over the past year and a half were essentially unusable. A critical part of the drum sound, the kick drum, was completely missing from the recordings. Without that low-end foundation, the entire album just fell apart. What was supposed to be their first major step forward had instead turned into a complete disaster. The blame seemed to rest at their drummer's feet. No pun intended. At first, they assumed it was a technical mistake, maybe the drum hadn't been mic'd properly or the signal hadn't been recorded. But Chris, who was also a drummer, knew that wasn't the case. The only explanation left was that the kick drum either hadn't been played consistently or was too weak to register on the recordings. Adding to the situation, the engineer they'd worked with was only 18 years old and pretty much just as inexperienced as they were in a studio setting. The lack of experience may have played a role in what went wrong, especially if he wasn't confident enough to challenge or correct the band during the recording process. What followed was a wave of reaction, frustration quickly set in, and as the band realized how serious the issue was, Chris bluntly stated, "There's no fucking kick anywhere. We can't fucking release this. This is fucking garbage." Chris even remarked in his book that most of the components of the band, their, and his years, the drum sound okay, but Chris was adamant that the recordings were unusable. Then came the heavier realization: the band had poured all of their money, everything they'd earned from gigs over the past year and a half into these recordings, and now it was gone. The album they'd worked towards was effectively lost. They still attempted to mix what they had, but deep down, they knew the truth. The recordings were beyond saving. The project was, as Kim later put it, dead on arrival. Kim reflected on this in his book, saying, "I'd been the one member of Soundgarden chosen to help mix our 'Deep Six' tracks, so I understood how the instruments and sounds all fit together, but I wasn't as experienced with the nuts and bolts of recording." The years since those recordings have remained buried, almost no one outside of the band has ever really heard them. Looking back, Kim acknowledged that the engineer should have caught the problem during the recording process, but the experience also exposed how little the band themselves understood about recording at the time. Without that crucial piece of the drum sound, the album was simply incomplete and there was no easy way to fix it. At the time, the band didn't realize that Scott was struggling with alcoholism, something he himself would later point to as a factor in the performance at the Cro. They were inexperienced when it came to that kind of issue and probably wouldn't have even confronted him if they'd recognized it in the first place. Although he was the newest member of the band, his age put him in a position of quiet authority. He drove a pickup and even had a wife and child. With more life experience than the others, he often served as a sort of older brother figure, offering guidance in his own way. In the aftermath of that failed studio session, tensions inside Soundgarden began to build around Scott's drumming. That technical disaster made everyone look harder at what was happening behind the kit. As they kept gigging and became more popular, playing to bigger audiences, but at the same time, more issues were starting to surface. Scott's playing became increasingly erratic, sometimes where he would literally fall off his drum stool in the middle of a song or get confused and count the band into the wrong track. At first, these moments seemed quirky or even darkly funny, but over time, they stopped being charming and started to feel like a liability. Especially as Soundgarden's local audience grew and the stakes got higher, the bigger problem though was a growing musical disconnect. The rest of the band was getting deeper into noisier, more experimental influences, bands like Butthole Surfers, Sonic Youth, Scratch Acid, Big Black, and practically, they'd wanted to strip things down rhythmically when the songs called for it, to use more minimal, mechanical or direct drumming. Scott pushed back. He didn't like that style. Didn't feel comfortable playing in a more restrained or rigid way, and in some cases, flat out refused to play songs that later ended up on the Screaming Life EP. All of this fed back into how the band viewed those recordings. The missing kick drum became a symbol of a deeper problem between where Soundgarden wanted to go creatively and what their drummer was willing or able to give them. That clash over performance and sound ultimately convinced Chris and Hiro that they had to make a change behind the kit, no matter how much they cared about Scott personally. This decision to part ways with Scott was the first real crisis involving the band, and they took it seriously. If Soundgarden was going to keep growing, they couldn't do it with Scott behind the kit, no matter how much they loved him personally. He'd been crucial in helping them establish themselves in Seattle and played on some of their earliest recordings, but musically and practically, they'd reached a point where they needed a change. The band members themselves realized that Scott's drumming, while perhaps heartfelt, wasn't always technically precise enough for the direction they wanted to go. This realization, coupled with his increasing unreliability, led to the difficult decision to replace him.