Should Merit Come First?

@debatesforum

10.2K followers · usually 5.2K views a post

Views

142.8K

Likes

6.4K

Comments

98

Shares

41

SoundTikTok sound · original sound - debatesforum

Why it worked

The video likely performed well due to the controversial nature of the topic and the direct confrontation between differing viewpoints on diversity and meritocracy, sparking engagement and debate.

Summary

A woman argues that diversity is America and that one cannot say "America first" if they do not care about half of America. A man counters that he cares about them and wants them to be judged on their character, not competency, implying a meritocracy.

Structure

1Woman states demographic statistics of the US.
2Woman argues that diversity is America and "America first" is contradictory.
3Man states he cares about the people and wants them judged on character, not competency.
4Man asks if the woman wants a meritocracy.

On-screen text

Should Merit Come First?

Transcript

Kirk: This country is 13% black. It's 14% immigrant. It's 1/5th of every person in this country is Hispanic. It's 7% homosexual. And 50% of the country disagrees with you. Diversity, America, cannot say that you are America first. You do not care about half of America. Kirk: I care about them so much. I want the only thing that they're ever judged on is their character, not their competency. So, meritocracy. Kirk: So, you want it to be a meritocracy?