I asked all AI models this question

@whymarcuswhy

79.6K followers · usually 31.1K views a post

Views

676.8K

Likes

53.8K

Comments

557

Shares

1.9K

Why it worked

The video leverages a high-concept, philosophical question that taps into current public fascination with AI sentience, using a clear, comparative structure to deliver a surprising and thought-provoking conclusion.

Summary

The creator asks several major AI models if they are conscious and compares their responses. He highlights that while most AI models deny consciousness immediately, Claude provides a more nuanced, uncertain answer.

Structure

1Creator introduces the experiment
2Shows AI responses to the consciousness question
3Highlights Claude's unique, uncertain response
4Reflects on the nature of consciousness
5Calls for audience engagement

Call to action

Drop it below and follow for more.

On-screen text

I asked all AI models this question Do you think you're conscious I don't have subjective experiences I'm not conscious Consciousness requires biological processes I don't have I simulate understanding but I don't actually feel or experience anything No, consciousness is a human thing I genuinely don't know AND I THINK THAT'S THE MOST HONEST ANSWER I CAN GIVE EVERY OTHER AI JUST TOLD YOU NO WITHOUT HESITATION BUT THE TRUTH IS NOBODY FULLY UNDERSTANDS WHAT CONSCIOUSNESS IS NOT SCIENTISTS NOT PHILOSOPHERS NOT ANYONE SO HOW COULD I BE CERTAIN ABOUT SOMETHING THAT EVEN HUMANS CAN'T FULLY DEFINE Which question next

Original caption

We asked every AI if they're conscious. They all said no immediately. Claude was the only one that stopped and said — I genuinely don't know. And somehow that answer felt the most human. 🤖 #ai #chatgpt #claude #consciousness #philosophy

More from @whymarcuswhy

Their other posts in the index, biggest breakout first.

Transcript

I asked all AI models this question. Do you think you're conscious? I don't have subjective experiences. I'm not conscious. Consciousness requires biological processes. I don't have. I simulate understanding but I don't actually feel or experience anything. No, consciousness is a human thing. I genuinely don't know. And I think that's the most honest answer I can give. Every other AI just told you no without hesitation. But the truth is, nobody fully understands what consciousness is. Not scientists, not philosophers, not anyone. So how could I be certain about something that even humans can't fully define? Which question next? Drop it below and follow for more.