Deftones long shelved album Eros is finally gone from myth to messy reality. Fans are having a full-on moral crisis about it. Recorded in 2008 and abandoned after bassist Chi Cheng's devastating car accident. Eros was always framed by the band as something deeply tied to a traumatic chapter. They didn't want to reopen. Over the years frontman Chino Moreno was reportedly said that the record was unfinished and would most likely never see the light of day, stressing that going back to them material didn't make emotional or artistic sense for the band. Instead, Deftones regrouped and reemerged with Diamond Eyes, using a different batch of songs to move forward creatively and personally. That's why the events of the last few days feel so relevant. Earlier this week, falls claiming to be from those Eros sessions popped up on a Deftones fan forum, reportedly including 11 tracks with working titles like "Destiny," "Smile," "Tramp Stamp," "Margo," and "Candy," plus demos tied to the "Eros" album. The upload was pulled relatively quickly. Threads were locked and the band hasn't publicly confirmed the leak, but not before the music was ripped, shared, and dissected across Reddit, Facebook groups, and YouTube commentary channels. For fans who've spent nearly two decades wondering what Eros sounded like, finally hearing it was surreal. Like a forbidden bootleg of an alternate timeline Deftones album suddenly landing in their lap. The reaction has been sharply divided, and that divide is the story. On one side, you've got fans describing the leak as phenomenal, calling it some of the most exciting material the band has done since the late 2000s, and talking about how it bridges the dark, dense textures of Saturday Night Wrist with the clarity and punch of Diamond Eyes. On the other side, there's a loud contingent saying the whole thing just feels wrong. Threads with hundreds of comments or fans admitting they feel guilty pressing play on the music, and that the band has explicitly chosen to bury. People point out that no one wants their demos to be judged by the entire internet, especially when those ideas are tethered to the darkest periods of their personal and professional lives. Some argue that forcing Eros into the light actually contradicts the band's decision to move on with Diamond Eyes, as part of healing and respecting the choices of a band that has chosen to leave its music in the vault. The band's 2006 record Saturday Night Wrist saw them enlist new producer Bob Ezrin and a choice they later regretted, as the band clashed with the producer. It was during this time, Moreno struggled with substance abuse and halfway through the recording process, he went off and worked on his own side project Team Sleep. In fact, the album's recording began in 2004 with the group ticking 2005 off. The album was eventually stitched together through song ideas the members sent through email. On tour for the album, Deftones set up a rehearsal space backstage and jammed new material. The band's 2006 record Saturday Night Wrist saw them enlist new producer Bob Ezrin and a choice they later regretted, as the band clashed with the producer. It was during this time, Moreno struggled with substance abuse and halfway through the recording process, he went off and worked on his own side project Team Sleep. In fact, the album's recording began in 2004 with the group ticking 2005 off. The album was eventually stitched together through song ideas the members sent through email. On tour for the album, Deftones set up a rehearsal space backstage and jammed new material.