I've been trying to put most of the blame for Cortis's appropriative existence on Hybe and not the individual members but we do have to address the elephant in the room James's mannerisms is not him being sassy and zesty he is performing a racist caricature back in the 2010s a common critique of white women and white gay men was that they would put on a strange persona the second they wanted to depict a sassier attitude the persona they were putting on didn't come out of a bubble they were mimicking the sapphire caricature per Doctor David Pilgrim professor of sociology in Ferris state University quote the sapphire caricature portrays black women as rude, loud, malicious, stubborn, and overbearing she is tart tongued and emasculating, one hand on hip and the other pointing and jabbing while violently and rhythmically rocking her head while watching this to help visualize a non black person putting on this caricature I'm gonna show you two memorable moments from 2010s television the first one will be the scene from American Dad Bitch I look like this homegirl don't chase homegirl gets chased homegirl get that paper all on her own Roger: stop that you're white and this extremely infamous argument that happened in Rupaul's Drag Race Season 6 Untucked Adore: This right know, that's the bitch that I know I don't know yes Mama Laganja: when I'm with my best friends I say yes Mama Adore: that ain't how you talk when I hang out with you when the cameras aren't here you should be able to pick up what I'm putting down but if you're somehow not I'll give you the K pop equivalent of these clips Wendy: girl what did you say girl mmm hmm mmm hmm you ain't doing that like I so let me just ask what is the difference between all the clips I just showed versus this one: Do you see what's behind me? what that is? The Eiffel Tower Bonjour, bonjour Bonjour, bonjour what that is? What that is? I will tower Paris!!! NOTE: Keep the quote of "(...) one hand on hip and the other pointing and jabbing while violently and rhythmically rocking her head" on your mind while watching this hi_im_gwen SpiderGwen. Oh, Gwen. Yes. The new generation. No, I agree. Yeah, I do understand. I do understand. Yeah. It's a tier list. It's a tier list. Nobody has to take it that seriously. But everybody has to have a No. 1 in. In a tier list. So. I'm sorry. Yeah, I do understand. Yeah. I do understand. Yeah. like honestly more if he was constantly putting on that caricature because at least fans are telling the truth but the fans are straight lying through their teeth he does not always act like that he only does that when he's trying to be quote unquote "sassy" which is why people are uncomfortable with that behavior because historically that is racist now I'm not saying that James himself is intentionally being racist because I don't know him personally quite in fact I'll give him the benefit of the doubt he probably about that behavior off of social media I'm sure he's not doing it with malicious intent but here's the thing about intent it doesn't equal impact like if you're going to recreate a video by a black woman and in that video you're going to be like jerking your head back and forth or side to side bucking at the camera, and clacking your fingers like you have long acrylics on whole time the lady in the video wasn't doing all that yes it's gonna come across as racist and I feel like if you come from a group whose success is entirely dependent on K pop stans who don't listen to black rappers but will listen to the same music if it comes from Asian men you owe it to yourself and black Americans to be a little bit brushed up on racial sensitivity and again I don't think he's being malicious and this is something that can very easily be like educated out of him but that can't happen when fans refuse to facilitate this conversation and instead shut it down every time within literally four hours of me releasing that first video on Cortis a few days ago I got called a literal ape in my DMs and ever since then I've been called everything under the sun but I don't really care that bad because I don't value the opinion of emotionally unregulated teenagers and racially insecure black K pop fans but I digress yes James is being microaggressive no I don't think he's intentionally being racist yes it's a conversation that should be had