Have you been sleeping wrong the whole time?

@steven

5.3M followers · usually 45.5K views a post

Views

707.9K

Likes

60.4K

Comments

911

13.9K

Why it worked

The video uses a strong, counter-intuitive hook about sleep quality and leverages the authority of a medical expert to challenge conventional medical practices, which creates high engagement.

Summary

Dr. Stasha Gominak explains how a lack of deep sleep can lead to serious health issues, even in young people. She argues that modern medicine often treats symptoms with drugs rather than addressing the underlying sleep-related causes.

Structure

1Introduction to the concept of non-restorative sleep
2Case study of an 18-year-old patient with no deep sleep
3Explanation of how the brain struggles to enter deep sleep
4Discussion on the long-term health risks of poor sleep
5Critique of the medical industry's reliance on symptom-masking drugs

On-screen text

HAVE YOU BEEN SLEEPING WRONG THE WHOLE TIME? Vitamin D Expert I've got this 18 year old to go to see me headache sleep study that shows none of these deep sleep sleeps for ten hours I ask her when we first meet your sleep? she says fine no deep and every 15 minutes her brain to get into one of these deep sleep and she wakes up to light sleep again the brain breaks into light sleep she thinks that she's asleep the whole night this shows the whole night sleep study over my five years of experience is horrifying because it's not just oh she's missing a little REM no deep this is a brain stem disorder of chemistry that's going to mean might meet me 10 years from now with a stroke I've taken care of 28 year olds who just had a stroke 28 28 year olds we associate stroke with being old and having diabetes and hypertension and heart disease I'm looking at this and for the very first time I have actually started to see the diseases that my neurology patients come in with and their relationship to sleep I'm doing sleep studies on anybody so I'm doing little kids I'm doing moms I'm doing dads I'm doing every single neurologic illness that comes in they're all abnormal this implies that the reason why you get a disease is because your sleep is not restorative it is what makes us last like we're not made of Teflon we're made of these biologic materials and they repair themselves every night that's a miracle if you view it through that lens then you start to question why is medicine doing what it is why as a physician am I trained to give the dr*g for this disease I'm trained to ask questions for the thing the person walks in for let's say burning in the feet I'm trained to make a little list of the diseases that have resulted in that and then give a dr*g for it and if we don't find a dr*g that reverses it then we give a dr*g that numbs the pain a little bit plastering over cracks we put a Band-Aid on it we're putting Band-Aids on these things instead of saying well what do you think led to this

Original caption

How important is your sleep quality? 💤 Dr Stasha Gominak explains why the quality of your sleep may matter just as much as the number of hours you get. She shares the story of a woman suffering from daily headaches who appeared to be getting almost no deep sleep at all. Sleep is meant to be restorative, so the real question is whether your body is ACTUALLY recovering when you sleep.

More from @steven

Their other posts in the index, biggest breakout first.

Transcript

The reason why you get a disease is because your sleep is not restorative. I've got this beautiful 18-year-old who's about to go to college, she comes to see me for daily headache. She has a sleep study that shows none of these phases of deep sleep. She usually sleeps for 10 hours. So when I ask her when we first meet, how's your sleep? She says fine. She has no deep sleep at all, and every 15 minutes or so, her brain is trying to get into one of these deep sleep phases, and she wakes up to light sleep again. So every time the brain tries to do this, it breaks to light sleep, light sleep, light sleep, light sleep. She thinks that she's asleep the whole night. This shows that she's asleep the whole night, but her sleep study over my five years of experience is horrifying because it's not just, oh, she's missing a little REM. She has no deep sleep at all. This is a brain stem disorder of chemistry that's going to mean she might meet me 10 years from now with a stroke. I've taken care of 28-year-olds who just had a stroke. 28, sorry? 28-year-olds. We associate stroke with being old and having diabetes and hypertension and heart disease. No, I'm looking at this and for the very first time, I have actually started to see the diseases that my neurology patients come in with and their relationship to sleep. I'm doing sleep studies on anybody who will let me. So I'm doing little kids, I'm doing moms, I'm doing dads, I'm doing every single neurologic illness that comes in, they're all abnormal. This implies that the reason why you get a disease is because your sleep is not restorative. It is what makes us last. Like we're not made of Teflon, we're made of these biologic materials and they repair themselves every night. That's a miracle. If you view it through that lens, then you start to question why is medicine doing what it is? Why as a physician am I trained to give the drug for this disease? I'm trained to ask questions for the thing the person walks in for. Let's say burning in the feet. I'm trained to make a little list of the diseases that have resulted in that and then give a drug for it. And if we don't find a drug that reverses it, then we give a drug that numbs the pain a little bit. We just kind of plastering over cracks. We put a Band-Aid on it. We're putting Band-Aids on these things instead of saying, well, what do you think led to this?