@tonyvanderhoef — 28x breakout selling FRESH

Loading video…

The Mamdani Markets are official,

@tonyvanderhoef

16.9K followers · usually 13.5K views a post

Views

355.9K

Likes

34.9K

Comments

2.4K

2.8K

Promoted product

FRESH

Why it worked

The video effectively uses a critical and comparative approach to highlight the perceived inefficiency of the Mamdani Markets' expansion, contrasting it with a government program (FRESH) that appears to achieve similar goals more effectively and with private funding. This narrative structure, combined with clear on-screen text and a direct critique, likely resonated with viewers interested in urban development, economics, and government policy.

Summary

The video critiques the Mamdani Markets' expansion, arguing that spending $70 million on five stores for a 30% discount on limited goods is a bad deal compared to existing competitors like Aldi and Walmart. It contrasts this with New York City's FRESH program, which uses private investment and tax incentives to successfully establish grocery stores in underserved areas without taxpayer funds.

Free account

Transcript, structure and on-screen text

6 beats, a 300-word transcript and 99 lines of on-screen text — the parts you need to write your own version.

Original caption

The Mamdani Markets are just another Mamdani Mirage… 🗽🛒🧐 Seventy million taxpayer dollars. Upfront. Just to open five stores. And what do you get for that? A thirty percent discount on a small list of goods. Aldi already beats that. Walmart already beats that. So the city is spending seventy million dollars to lose to competitors that already exist, for free. And that's before a single day of operating costs. Staff, inventory, maintenance... none of that thirty percent discount pays for itself. And for what? A narrow selection of basic goods. No pharmacy. No deli counter. No bakery. None of the services a real grocery store competes on. So what you have in reality is higher costs, with smaller discount and fewer options with no services. And what makes it worse is New York already has a program that does this right. It's called FRESH, zoning bonuses and tax breaks for private grocers who build in underserved neighborhoods. Since 2009, thirty stores open. One hundred seventy-seven million dollars, not from taxpayers, from private investment. Fourteen hundred jobs. Zero public dollars on construction. So why not just use that? Because FRESH doesn't get him what he actually wants. His own words: a store "focused on keeping prices low, not making a profit." That only works if government owns it. And that's why he keeps saying "food desert." It sounds like there's no other option, except there's reportedly forty-five grocery stores within a thirty-five-minute walk of the site he picked. The desert isn't real. It's the justification he needs to make ownership the story. The math was never the point and it’s not really about savings. It’s about control. It’s about socialism. Sources: https://edc.nyc/program/food-retail-expansion-support-health-fresh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zohran_Mamdani https://www.city-journal.org/article/democratic-socialism-capitalism-mamdani-new-york https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/mayor-loves-bodegas-building-taxpayer-110010657.html — #mamdani #nyc #politics #socialism #capitalism