Hook
More breakout videos from this creator.
In 1978, a linguist at Berkeley, Deborah Tannen, who is the author of this book, one of my favorites, taped a Thanksgiving dinner with five friends. She and two others had grown up in New York, two guests were from Los Angeles, and one was from London. Listening back to this, uh, audio-taped conversation, she noticed that the New Yorkers shared a way of talking that she called high involvement. With each other, it made the conversation super lively and close. With everyone else, it kept backfiring, and there were three key habits to this. Number one was New Yorkers jumped in while everyone else was talking. So with things like, "I do that, too," you know, jumping in, right? Or by finishing the other person's sentence. To them, it showed that they were involved. But the Californians in the conversation stopped talking. They heard it as an interruption. One said later that even when he had the floor, he never felt like he was part of the flow because he was always anticipating someone jumping in in front of him. The second was pauses. The New Yorkers left almost no gap between turns. The others kept waiting for the pause, uh, and that was their turn, and then they would jump in. Uh, a New Yorker would beat the pause, and so the conversation would keep going. Other people would have less of an opportunity to speak and so on. And then the third was what she called machine gun questions, quick, clipped questions, one after another. In one conversation she recorded, a New York woman met a man from LA. "You live in LA? Visiting there? What do you do there? Do you... Are, are you an artist? Writer?" You know, like, like boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. Um, and, and his experience was that he was feeling interrogated, and in her experience was she was trying to be engaging. So the same habits can have very different meanings. To, to the New Yorkers in this conversation, it was, it was like, "I'm really into this. I'm really engaged." And by extension, you're someone that I'm engaged with. But to the others, it came across as pushy and annoying, sort of the stereotypical view of the pushy New Yorker, which really, in a sense, is more of a clash of conversational style than anything else. So I'd be curious what your experience is. This is of course just one study. Um, she went on to have a very impressive linguistic, sociolinguistic career. But I think this is a very interesting study, how she looked at these habits of conversation and saw how different people can see the same habit in different ways. Someone might feel that they're being very involved, but at the same time someone else might feel that they're pushy and annoying. Um, love to hear your thoughts and experience with this in general and with New Yorkers.