Did she murder three of her children? Yes. Do I think she should go to prison for it? No, probably not. I'm a forensic scientist and a former CSI. This is Lindsay Clancy, her trial starts this week. The prosecution in her case wants her to go to prison for murdering her children. I'm not sure that's a good idea. I don't know if it's gonna happen. I'm curious to know what do you think about this case and do you think Lindsay Clancy should go to prison right now? Obviously, we don't know all of the evidence because the trial is just getting underway. But I do want to talk about what we know so far. Admittedly, Lindsay Clancy murdered her three children. She strangled all of her children with exercise bands. Lindsay was alone with her children for a little while because her husband Patrick had gone out to CVS and to pick up some takeout food. And when he came home, Lindsay had strangled all three of her children to death. She had cut her wrists and neck and jumped out of a second floor window of her house. She lived. None of her children did. Although the youngest of her children did live for a couple of days. There is really no debate about what happened in this case and what Lindsay did. In an amended complaint filed in Norfolk Superior Court, Lindsay Clancy alleges a network of psychiatric providers misdiagnosed her, failed to properly treat what she says is bipolar disorder with postpartum onset and prescribed a changing regimen of medications that allegedly worsened her condition before the Jan. 24, 2023, deaths of her children. The complaint accuses the defendants of medical malpractice and negligence, alleging they failed to recognize that Clancy's reported intrusive thoughts were actually auditory hallucinations that made her a danger to herself and her children. Lindsay Clancy did everything a situation could do, the lawsuit says. She sought treatment, went to emergency contacted crisis services, admitted and repeatedly reported her. The state says that it was premeditated, that she intentionally sent her husband out of the house, mapped out how long he was going to be gone and used that opportunity to commit these murders and then tried unsuccessfully to end her own life. But her defense was not in her right state of mind and she cannot be held criminally responsible for what she did. And looking at it on its face, I tend to agree with the defense. Now, I haven't seen the evidence, so I'm just telling you what I can piece together from the news. Patrick Clancy is one of the more than 200 people who could be called to testify. Patrick, along with his wife Lindsay, have maintained that the doctors who treated her misdiagnosed and overmedicated her, causing her to hallucinate voices telling her to kill her kids. The allegations are central to lawsuits claiming that medical professionals failed to diagnose her escalating postpartum psychosis before the deadly tragedy. Not mentally ill. She was overmedicated, like severely overmedicated. And all of her attempts to get help failed. Nobody could help her. The fact that she was admittedly having auditory hallucinations, she was hearing voices, she had thoughts of harming the children. She thought that people could hear her thoughts. Her husband Patrick allegedly contacted nurse practitioner Rebecca Jollotta's office on Dec. 15 to report that his wife had suffered a devastating week and was hearing voices all day, the complaint says. The filing also alleges Lindsay Clancy told family members she had thoughts of harming the children. At the same time, she allegedly believed people could hear her thoughts and feared she would be locked in a hospital and lose her children. Days later, after starting Seroquel, she allegedly developed suicidal ideation and began hearing a voice telling her she would not be the same and wanted to die. She was declining rapidly. She was in fact severely mentally ill. And she tried to admit herself into a hospital, was kind of successful. She got checked in on New Year's Eve. Nobody saw her until January 3rd because of the holiday weekend. And then five days later, they checked her out. She was really only under the care of a physician in the psych ward for two days. Back in outpatient care, the lawsuit says, Clancy continued to deteriorate. On Jan. 16, she allegedly reported hallucinations saying, 'You should harm the children' and 'You should kill yourself.' Dr. Jennifer Tufts then prescribed Amitriptyline, another antidepressant, according to the complaint. On Jan. 23, the suit says, Tufts increased the Amitriptyline dose. That night, Clancy allegedly did not sleep. He told her doctor about some really concerning things. She was having hallucinations. Voices telling her to hurt her children, to hurt herself. They put her on more drugs. When it didn't work, they upped her dose, which just led to more insomnia. This is like the recipe for a psychotic break. The next day, the complaint alleges, Clancy was severely depressed and experiencing nonstop suicidal hallucinations. After her husband left to pick up takeout, a commanding voice allegedly told her it was her last chance and ordered her to kill the children so she could kill herself. The lawsuit claims Clancy then entered a dissociative, dream-like state before strangling the children and trying to kill herself by taking medications, cutting her wrists and neck, and jumping from a second-floor window. Cora and Dawson died that day. Three days later, Clancy has pleaded not guilty to the charges in her case. She started experiencing nonstop hallucinations. And she claims her husband left to pick up his, the voices in her head told her, hey, hey, last chance and so she acted. She said she was in a dissociative dreamlike state. Took her children down into the basement and ended their lives. And then she tried to end her own life. After she took pills, cut her wrists and cut her neck, she jumped out of the second floor of the building and her husband, when he came home, found her outside laying on the ground, bleeding. She is paralyzed from the sternum down. Lindsay Clancy's lawyer warns she could kill herself if medical needs not met during murder trial. She's not a danger to others, that's for sure. But she's surely a danger to herself, he said Wednesday. It's not on me. If this woman kills herself during this trial, which there is a very real probability that could happen, it's on somebody, and it's not on me. Assistant District Attorney indicated the state would accommodate Clancy's needs in accordance with her physician assistant. She is not mentally healthy. She is incredibly unwell. She is under constant supervision at the hospital where she has been since this event took place. In court previously, her lawyer basically said, hey, she is always struggling with very intense suicidal ideations. She has to be watched constantly. This was such an issue that her attorney said, hey, she can't be transported to and from court like a normal inmate. She needs to come in an ambulance. And he said, it's not on me. If this woman kills herself during this trial, which there is a very real probability that could happen, it's on somebody, and it's not on me. It seems extraordinarily unlikely to me that this woman would be successfully malingering for years. The issue here is she is responsible for ending the lives of her children, which she obviously is. The issue here that is going to be front and center is whether she is criminally responsible. She cannot be criminally responsible if she was not same. Now, obviously, we're going to have to wait and see. There's probably going to be more evidence, obviously, that comes out in a really long trial. We've only scratched the surface of the information that's publicly available. But I want to know, what do you think? The trial hasn't started yet. We're going to wait to hear all your first impressions. Do you think she should go to prison for what she did? Do you think she should even be prosecuted? Do you think the prosecution should recognize that she is mentally unwell and she needs to be in a hospital? Let me know in the comments. The trial hasn't started yet. We're going to wait to hear all your first impressions. Do you think she should go to prison for what she did? Or do you think the prosecution should recognize that she is mentally unwell? And she needs to be in a hospital? Let me know in the comments.