1 of 4
Why MTSS isn't working
MTSS Tiers
Tier 3
Targeted help
for specific
student groups
Tier 2
Tier 1
If Most of your students
are in tier 2 or tier 3.
You don't have a student
problem or a parent
problem.
You have a tier 1 problem.
I've spent a lot of time on
talking about the gap
between how schools are supposed
to work and how they do work,
and MTSS is one of the
most clear examples of
that gap.
Look for part 1 for
an explainer on
what it is
I wanna talk about why
MTSS so often fails,
what it means when most
of your kids end up in
intervention,
and what the research
says you're supposed to
actually do about it.
Research
Research on MTSS is
very, very clear that it only will
work if the tier 1 is strong.
The tier 1 is supposed
to be meeting behaviorally
and academically
is supposed to be meeting
the needs of 80 to 90%
of your students
when that is not happening
So when you have 40
50% of your students in
tier 2 or tier three,
that is a diagnostic
problem. It tells you that there is
something wrong with
your tier 1,
not that there's
something wrong
with your kids.
Think of it this way. If 70%
of your students fail a
test, like, is there a chance that
they just were all being
knuckleheads? Okay.
But like if you are seeing this as a
pattern, then it should tell you that
instead of giving them
tutoring,
that we should be
adjusting what we are
assessing,
what we're teaching, and
what we're assessing.
Intervention is not
supposed to be the primary answer
for the majority of students.
It is supposed to be the
exception.
Something is wrong
upstream,
it's of course, happens on
the behavior side.
Two, a lot of schools treat
behavior in academic
separately,
separate teams, separate su
separate supports. But
the truth is,
if you have a student
who's struggling behaviorally,
they're probably
struggling academically
and vice versa.
And if you separate the two sy
the
you are not
missing the whole picture.
Most common
implementation failures
that the research identifies.
One
weak tier 1 instruction
that was never strong
enough to serve most
students.
No universal screening,
so you never actually know
who needs what.
And treating th
the tiers as
like a permanent thing
instead of individualized.
Or moving. A student in
tier 2 is supposed to
either move back down to
tier 1
or back or up to
tier 3, depending on how the
support is working.
They should not be s
And a student in tier 3
should move up to tier 2
or be referred to, uh,
IEP team if they're not
moving.
One thing that I will say is like,
I know if you have 50%
of your kids who let you
have identified as tier 2,
then it
it's exhausting to track the data for th
It's exhausting to keep up wit
I can absolutely relate
that.
But the thing about it is
that data is what you
will Show your admin,
and they will show their
admin that there is a
problem with the tier 1,
and the tier 1 needs to be fixed.
If tier 1 is weak. No
amount of intervention
will fix that.
And if your behavior and
academic teams or, uh,
meetings are not like, integra
integrating both,
then you are not
getting the whole picture of the kid.