Every Christmas my grandmother seats the grandchildren in order of how often they visit. My daughter is nine and has sat by the kitchen door since she could walk. Grandma Edith kept a little notebook by her phone. Every visit got a tally mark. On Christmas Eve she read the numbers out loud and pointed at chairs. "Amos, 52, sit by me. Leticia, 48. Then she looked at my daughter, Selena. Kitchen door zero. And kids. The Varas kids. They lived 10 minutes away. I'd stopped visiting years ago because my sister Vera told me Grandma wanted space from me after my divorce. She said, "Christmas and that's it. Vera told me, "Don't push it, or you'll make it worse." So I didn't push. But Selena wanted to know her great-grandma. She'd mail her a card every month. Drawings, report cards, school photos. She licked the stamps herself. Grandma never wrote back. Not once. This year we got there at 6 PM. Vera was already in the kitchen sorting Grandma's mail like always. "Helping prescriptions, bringing the mail in. Selena, Grandma's kitchen door, Grandma said without looking up. Selena sat. She didn't complain. Never. Halfway through dinner she tugged my sleeve. "Mom," she whispered. "Aunt Vera's bag is on the hook. It's open." "Don't touch other people's stuff." "I didn't, but I can see my handwriting." I leaned back from Selena's chair, you could see straight into the tote hanging by the door. Envelopes. Purple, green, reindeer, Selena. November. "Where are you going?" Vera said too fast. Bathroom. I went to the bathroom. The table. That's mine, Vera said. Standing. "These are not yours!" I pulled out a rubber banded stack. Thick. Every envelope addressed to Edith Balogun in a kid's handwriting. Everyone still sealed. The table went silent. "What is that, Grandma?" "Cards," Selena said quietly. "I send you one every month since first grade. Grandma stared. "Gotten because mail," Vera laughed. "Oh my god. I bring the mail in because Vera takes your mail. I said, "Vera, you needed space after the divorce. Only." Grandma turned to Vera very slowly. Asked, "Never?" "You told me she was busy." "Didn't." "She didn't care." She tapped a notebook by her plate. I gave your kids every over. A zero." It's a seating chart. It's not that deep. She flipped the notebook to the back page. There was a list I'd never seen. Names, percentages. "Will," she said. "The ones who show up get the most." "Who?" "Ago, one Vera. Grandma, she's twisting this. She said, "The envelopes." The ones that were there. Years me." Grandma pulled the stack down. Sit down, Vera. Grandma counted the envelopes out loud. All the way to thirty-seven. Then she picked up her pen, crossed out the zero next to Selena's name and wrote in its place. Thirty-seven, she said. "These from chair beside Selena. Selena waited. Then turned the notebook to the back page again. Drew a line straight through Vera's name, and looked at the empty chair by the kitchen door. "Vera." "Sitting." You know where you're sitting.