I brought one sleeve of paper plates to my sister-in-law's table. My husband's sister, Aisha, hosts Thanksgiving every year. And every year there's a group chat with assignments. I usually get something real, like mashed potatoes or a pie. Two years ago, I made a pecan pie from scratch. And at the end of the night, I found it in her kitchen trash, like, the whole thing, barely cut. When I asked, she said, "Oh, somebody must have knocked it off the counter. It was sitting perfectly upright in the bag." This year the group chat went up in October. Alonzo's mom was on Turkey. His brother was on rolls and wine. Aisha's Pilates friend Jen was on charcuterie. "Esperanza: paper plates, 40 count." Little heart. Alonzo shrugged and said, "Honestly, that's less work for you." Which, fine, I guess. I wasn't going to fight over plates. Then like a week before, Aisha called me. She said, "Hey, so just a heads up, we're doing seating differently this year. The dining table only fits 14. So you guys and the kids are going to be at the folding table in the garage. I've got a space heater out there, it's really cute, I promise." "Okay," I said, "who's at the dining table?" And she just listed it. Her and her husband, their two kids, Alonzo's brother and his wife, Jen and Jen's husband and a couple of her neighbors. Brother's your. She said, "Don't kids grandpa. Grandpa Francis spills everything, so he's out there with you." Grandpa Francis is 91. He's Alonzo's grandpa. He's the whole reason the family does Thanksgiving in the first place. I told Alonzo that night, and he said, "It's one dinner, babe. It's her house." So I dropped it. And two days before Thanksgiving, Aisha posts on Instagram. It's her dining table, all set. Tablecloth, candles and her wedding china. 14 place settings. Caption said, "Getting the table ready for the people I love most." And I just sat there looking at it because it finally clicked. The China was for the dining room. The paper plates were for the garage. There were eight of us at the folding table, me, Alonzo, our three kids, Grandpa Francis, Alonzo's cousin Warren and his girlfriend, who apparently also didn't make the cut. 10 was plenty. In the car, Alonzo saw the bag and said, "That's it? Just one?" I said, "Count the garage." He actually did, like on his fingers, and then he didn't say anything else the whole drive. Thanksgiving comes, we get there at 2 PM and I hand Aisha the sleeve. She looks at it and goes, "Is the rest in the car?" I said, "No, that's it." She was because out dinner was fine. Honestly, the garage was freezing, even with the heater. Francis told stories the whole time. And the kids thought, "Last time I ate in a garage was 1958," almost around dessert. And that's when Aisha comes into the garage, kind of fast, and says, "Esperanza, where are the plates?" I said, "We're using them." She said, "No, the other 30. I need them for pie." And people need plates to take leftovers home. That's what they were for. I thought, "Oh, the garage goes, chat!" Said, "Where you counted." Then Alonzo's mom had followed her out and she said, "Talking of a kids wasn't mom table, Francis, coat on just Aisha said, "Supposed seriously?" I said, "The good China. It's been all even plate mom room a chat!"