I ordered every Thanksgiving pie in the one flavor my mother-in-law hates. So my mother-in-law Phyllis hates pecan. Not dislikes, hates. She's told everyone at every holiday for 11 years "Pecan tastes like a candle." Who've bit. Thanksgiving has been at our house for six years now since my husband Otto and I got a place big enough. I cook everything. Turkey, sides, rolls from scratch. Phyllis brings the pies. That one. That was the deal from year one. She said, "You handle dessert, and don't worry about it." And every year the pies are the same. Apple, pumpkin, and a cherry nobody eats. If anyone else brings dessert, it kind of disappears to the back of the counter. One year my brother brought a cheesecake and she said, "We'll save that for tomorrow." And it never came out. Fine. Whatever. It's her thing. Except last year I made one pie myself. Just one. It was my grandmother's recipe, I passed in the spring, and I wanted it on the table. I told Phyllis about it in October. I said, "I'm making one pecan for my side, you don't have to touch it." She said, "Okay honey." Thanksgiving day, I go to set out dessert and my pie is not on the counter where I left it. I checked the fridge. Not there. I asked Otto. He doesn't know. I finally find it in the outside trash can, still in its dish, with a paper towel laid over it like she'd tucked it in. I asked her about it in the kitchen, quietly. She said, "Oh, it had to crack down the middle. I didn't want you to be embarrassed." She said, "Well, it does now." And she laughed. My sister-in-law laughed. Otto said, "Mom," in that voice that means nothing. I didn't say anything else. I served her three pies. I smiled. I washed her dishes and sent her home with leftovers. Otto said in bed that night, "She didn't mean it like that." I said, "Like what?" He didn't have an answer. So that September, Phyllis calls Otto and says she's going to be taking it easy this Thanksgiving and won't be doing pies. Can we handle it? Otto says, "Sure." He told me and I said, "Okay, that's all I said." He told me later I called the good bakery in town, the one with a line out the door. Pies. Six pies. Bourbon pecan, maple pecan, chocolate pecan, pecan with a short bread crust, salted caramel pecan, and a plain pecan because I'm not a monster. It came to $214. I paid it. Otto saw the confirmation on the iPad. He said, "Is this a joke?" I said, "No, he said it's dessert." He said, "You know she won't eat any of them." I said, "She's taking it easy." He said, "She's going to lose it." I said, "Then she can bring her own pie." That was never a problem before. He asked if I was at least getting one apple for the kids. I said, "The kids like pecan." I said, "Since when?" I said, "Since yesterday." He didn't warn her. I know because of what happened. Thanksgiving, 7 PM. Phyllis comes in with a bottle of wine and nothing else. Dinner's fine. She compliments the turkey twice, which for her is basically a standing ovation. Around 5:30 PM, I clear plates and start bringing out dessert. And I set them down one at a time. All six pies, all the same color. What is this? Not a question. "Pecan." She said, "There's looked at the plate. My sister-in-law said, "Oh my god." I couldn't tell you if it was a good one or a bad one. Phyllis said, "You know I don't eat pecan." I said, "I do know that." I picked up the knife and cut into the first one. My grandmother's pie didn't have a crack. Nobody talked. My nephew asked if there was ice cream. There was. She sat there the whole time with a cup of coffee in front of her and nothing in front of her. At one point she said, kind of to the room, "I would have brought pies if someone had asked." I said, "You said you were taking it easy." She said, "I'm processing." "Tell her she can take all the time she needs." Everyone else. One had. Otto had two pieces, which I'm counting as a vote. At 7 PM, she got her coat. She said, "I hope you're happy." I said, "I am actually." "Take a pie." She didn't take a pie. She hasn't called Otto since. "Processing."