SO CARNEY WENT SILENT FOR 72 HOURS. TRUMP BLINKED ON HOUR 73. HERE IS WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED. AT 4:44 PM ON A MONDAY, MARK CARNEY CONCLUDED A BILATERAL TELEPHONE CALL WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, SET DOWN THE PHONE, AND ISSUED A SINGLE INSTRUCTION TO HIS COMMUNICATIONS STAFF. NOTHING. NO STATEMENT, NO READOUT, NO CHARACTERIZATION OF THE CALL'S CONTENTS, NO BACKGROUND BRIEFING TO JOURNALISTS, NO DIPLOMATIC NOTATION FOR THE PRESS POOL. NOTHING. THE INSTRUCTION WAS COMMUNICATED IN WRITING TO THE PRIME MINISTER'S COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTOR, TO THE PRESS SECRETARY, TO THE SENIOR ADVISOR RESPONSIBLE FOR TRADE WAR MEDIA STRATEGY, AND TO THE AMBASSADOR IN WASHINGTON. THE INSTRUCTION WAS SPECIFIC ENOUGH THAT SOURCES WHO REVIEWED IT DESCRIBE IT AS THE MOST PRECISE COMMUNICATIONS DIRECTIVE ISSUED BY THE CANADIAN PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE SINCE THE TRADE WAR BEGAN. IT SAID, THE CANADIAN GOVERNMENT WILL MAKE NO PUBLIC COMMUNICATION OF ANY REGARDING THE CONTENTS, TONE, CHARACTER OR OUTCOME OF THE CALL THAT CONCLUDED AT 4:44 PM UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE FROM THE PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE. FURTHER NOTICE WAS DEFINED IN THE DIRECTIVE AS AN EXPLICIT WRITTEN AUTHORIZATION THAT THE PRIME MINISTER WOULD TRANSMIT WHEN HE JUDGED THE MOMENT CORRECT. THE DIRECTIVE CONTAINED ONE ADDITIONAL LINE THAT SOURCES DESCRIBE AS THE LINE THAT MADE 72 HOURS POSSIBLE. THE PRIME MINISTER HAS ASSESSED THAT THE OPTIMAL RESPONSE TO THIS CALL IS THE RESPONSE THAT DEMONSTRATES CANADA HAS NO IMMEDIATE RESPONSE TO MAKE ON THE AMERICAN SIDE. THE CALL'S CONCLUSION PRODUCED THE OPPOSITE OF SILENCE. WITHIN 40 MINUTES OF THE CALL ENDING, THE WHITE HOUSE COMMUNICATIONS OPERATION HAD PREPARED A THREE PARAGRAPH CHARACTERIZATION OF THE CALL THAT DESCRIBED A PRODUCTIVE DISCUSSION, EXPRESSED CONFIDENCE IN THE PATH FORWARD, AND QUOTED THE PRESIDENT AS SAYING THE TWO LEADERS HAD MADE REAL PROGRESS ON THE ISSUES THAT MATTER MOST TO BOTH COUNTRIES. THE READOUT WAS POSTED TO THE WHITE HOUSE WEBSITE AT 5:24 PM MONDAY. IT WAS PICKED UP BY EVERY MAJOR AMERICAN NEWS OUTLET WITHIN MINUTES. IT WAS FOLLOWED AT 6:11 PM BY A PRESIDENTIAL SOCIAL MEDIA POST DESCRIBING THE CALL AS VERY GOOD AND VERY PRODUCTIVE AND SAYING THAT GREAT THINGS WERE HAPPENING WITH CANADA. AT 7:30 PM, THE WHITE HOUSE PRESS SECRETARY HELD AN IMPROMPTU BRIEFING IN THE STAKEOUT POSITION OUTSIDE THE WEST WING AT WHICH SHE ELABORATED ON THE READOUT DESCRIBED THE ATMOSPHERE OF THE CALL AS POSITIVE, FORWARD LOOKING, AND DECLINED TO PROVIDE SPECIFIC DETAILS BECAUSE THE CONVERSATIONS WERE ONGOING. THE CANADIAN GOVERNMENT SAID NOTHING BY TUESDAY MORNING, THE READOUT AND THE SOCIAL MEDIA AND THE PRESS SECRETARY'S BRIEFING HAD PRODUCED A SPECIFIC AND COMPOUNDING PROBLEM FOR THE AMERICAN SIDE THAT SOURCES FAMILIAR WITH BOTH GOVERNMENTS COMMUNICATIONS MONITORING DESCRIBE AS THE MOST UNCOMFORTABLE DIPLOMATIC SILENCE THE WHITE HOUSE HAD EXPERIENCE SINCE THE TRADE WAR BEGAN. THE PROBLEM WAS THIS: THE WHITE HOUSE HAD PUBLICLY CHARACTERIZED A CALL AS PRODUCTIVE AND PROGRESS MAKING, AND THE OTHER PARTY TO THE CALL MADE NO STATEMENT CONFIRMING OR DENYING THAT CHARACTERIZATION IN DIPLOMATIC COMMUNICATIONS. A READOUT CHARACTERIZING PRODUCTIVE THAT IS NOT MATCHED BY A CORRESPONDING READOUT FROM THE OTHER SIDE, OR AT MINIMUM NOT CONTRADICTED, CAN CARRY AN IMPLIED CONFIRMATION. THE AMERICAN SIDE HAD BEEN OPERATING ON THAT IMPLIED CONFIRMATION. BY TUESDAY MORNING, 38 HOURS INTO THE SILENCE, SOURCES AT THREE MAJOR FINANCIAL NEWS OUTLETS HAD BEGUN REACHING OUT TO THE CANADIAN PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE ASKING WHETHER A READOUT WAS FORTHCOMING OR SILENCE ITSELF WAS A COMMUNICATION. THE MO DID NOT ANSWER THOSE INQUIRIES. THE SILENCE DEEPENED. WARREN BUFFETT, MONITORING BOTH THE WHITE HOUSE READOUT AND THE CANADIAN SILENCE FROM THE MOMENT THE CALL ENDED, OFFERED AN INITIAL OBSERVATION ON TUESDAY AFTERNOON THAT SOURCES DESCRIBE AS THE MOST IMMEDIATELY WIDELY DISTRIBUTED OF HIS TRADE WAR COMMENTARIES, SHARED WITHIN THE FINANCIAL COMMUNITY AND THE DIPLOMATIC COMMUNITY, SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH THE SPECIFICITY THAT BELONGS TO SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTOOD WHAT THE SILENCE MEANT BEFORE MOST OBSERVERS HAD STARTED ASKING THE QUESTION. IN 62 YEARS OF NEGOTIATION, BUFFETT SAID, I HAVE WATCHED SILENCE DEPLOYED AS A STRATEGIC INSTRUMENT MANY TIMES. IT IS UNDERUTILIZED BECAUSE IT REQUIRES A SPECIFIC KIND OF DISCIPLINE THAT MOST PARTIES IN HIGH STAKES NEGOTIATIONS CANNOT MAINTAIN. THE DISCIPLINE TO SAY NOTHING WHEN SAYING SOMETHING WOULD FEEL MORE POWERFUL, MORE ACTIVE, MORE IN CONTROL. THE WHITE HOUSE HAD BEEN OPERATING ON THAT IMPLIED CONFIRMATION. BY TUESDAY MORNING, 38 HOURS INTO THE SILENCE, SOURCES AT THREE MAJOR FINANCIAL NEWS OUTLETS HAD BEGUN REACHING OUT TO THE CANADIAN PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE ASKING WHETHER A READOUT WAS FORTHCOMING OR SILENCE ITSELF WAS A COMMUNICATION. THE MO DID NOT ANSWER THOSE INQUIRIES. THE SILENCE DEEPENED. WARREN BUFFETT, MONITORING BOTH THE WHITE HOUSE READOUT AND THE CANADIAN SILENCE FROM THE MOMENT THE CALL ENDED, OFFERED AN INITIAL OBSERVATION ON TUESDAY AFTERNOON THAT SOURCES DESCRIBE AS THE MOST IMMEDIATELY WIDELY DISTRIBUTED OF HIS TRADE WAR COMMENTARIES, SHARED WITHIN THE FINANCIAL COMMUNITY AND THE DIPLOMATIC COMMUNITY, SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH THE SPECIFICITY THAT BELONGS TO SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTOOD WHAT THE SILENCE MEANT BEFORE MOST OBSERVERS HAD STARTED ASKING THE QUESTION. IN 62 YEARS OF NEGOTIATION, BUFFETT SAID, I HAVE WATCHED SILENCE DEPLOYED AS A STRATEGIC INSTRUMENT MANY TIMES. IT IS UNDERUTILIZED BECAUSE IT REQUIRES A SPECIFIC KIND OF DISCIPLINE THAT MOST PARTIES IN HIGH STAKES NEGOTIATIONS CANNOT MAINTAIN. THE DISCIPLINE TO SAY NOTHING WHEN SAYING SOMETHING WOULD FEEL MORE POWERFUL, MORE ACTIVE, MORE IN CONTROL.