5 instrument is would NOT play in band

@mattheww_mckenna

578.2K followers · usually 55.6K views a post

Views

240.1K

Likes

23.7K

Comments

2.0K

Shares

1.5K

SoundTikTok sound · original sound - mattheww_mckenna

Why it worked

The video taps into a common experience and opinion among musicians and band members, creating relatable content. The listicle format with a clear ranking and brief, opinionated explanations makes it easy to consume and share.

Summary

The creator lists five instruments they would not play in a band, ranking them from least desirable to most undesirable. They explain their reasoning for each choice, often citing the instrument's perceived lack of prominence or difficulty in blending with other band instruments.

Structure

1Introduction: 5 instruments I wouldn't play in a band
2Number 5: Clarinet - often unheard in a band setting
3Number 4: Trombone - cool sound but difficult slide work
4Number 3: Piccolo - not used much, not a focal point
5Number 2: Baritone - overshadowed by other brass instruments
6Number 1: Bass Clarinet - not commonly used and gets drowned out

On-screen text

5 instrument is would NOT play in band 5. Clarinet 4. Trombone 3. Piccolo 2. Baritone 1. Bass clarinet

Original caption

Would you play these? #band #top5 #bandkids #instrument

More from @mattheww_mckenna

More breakout videos from this creator.

Transcript

5 instrument is would NOT play in band Here we go. Number 5, the clarinet. Maybe I'm a hater, but genuinely, the clarinet is one of the least hard instruments in any band. I think the clarinet actually sounds pretty good by itself, but in a band, as a whole, you can't really hear them that much, especially on a football field. Number 4, the trombone. The trombone is genuinely one of the coolest sounding instruments. However, your boy just can't deal with all of the slide work. Like I said, it's not the worst out there, so that's why it's not making the bottom three. Number 3, we're going with the Piccolo. I frankly, it's just not used for very much. That's really it. It's not that I really love or hate it. It's just me personally. I'd rather have an instrument that's more the focal point of a song. Number 2, the Baritone. Now, I am not hating on my baritone players out there, but we have to admit something. You are overshadowed by trumpets, trombones, tubas, and French horns. Genuinely, you are the bottom of every single brass instrument out there. There is just no way I'd pick you to play. What number 1, the Bass clarinet. To be honest, this is just not the most used instrument out there and it kind of gets drowned out when you're listening to everything else.