Meta Glasses x Kylie Jenner roll out was accidental rage bait
and what Emma chamberlain understands about the creator economy that meta clearly doesn't.
In the past week I've been hearing a lot of discourse about two separate things
that I think are actually more connected than anyone's making them seem.
The first, everyone hates meta glasses,
and the second is that all influencers and people who participate in the creator economy
are talking about how much they think it's right now changing.
The common thread is Kylie Jenner and the promotion of the meta glasses
using Kylie Jenner as a face.
I specifically want to talk about Emma Chamberlain's comments
on Emma Grade's podcast that she thinks that influencer culture is dying
or the ability for influencers to influence is changing.
And the Vox article that featured Audrey Peters
talking about how her door dashing her Starbucks every morning
was just a bit for rage bait.
Let's first talk about the meta glasses.
I think meta put Kylie Jenner as the face of the meta glasses
because they very transparently
want to reach a demographic
that tech is not reaching very effectively right now.
And definitely the meta glasses are not reaching very effectively right now,
which is what I imagine they think is Kylie Jenner's core
audience demographic.
The young trendy girly pop.
Loves beauty, loves fashion,
and might be pretty easily influenceable.
I think they failed to estimate
how much scrutiny anything a Kardashian Jenner gets
and how much critical thinking the Kardashian
and Jenner's moves invite in
from their audience.
Not just those influenceable girly pops,
but the entire world who look to the Kardashian Jenners
to make cultural commentary
about where our society is
and where our society is going.
By splashing out as big as they have
on this Kylie Jenner meta glasses collaboration,
they have gotten probably
just as many eyes as they hoped a collaboration with Kylie Jenner would get them.
But not all of those eyes have been complimentary.
Actually, instead invited people to have a larger sense
of an awareness of everything
that is wrong with the meta glasses
in today's society.
Meta's an unsolicited example.
You know the influencer that was filming those lawyers
making out in the public park bench?
I think maybe even just a year ago,
people would have looked at that and said, you know what? That's crazy.
Those two are cheating on their significant other.
We should try to dog them and cancel them.
Because look what happened with that couple at the corduroy concert.
But since AI has taken over so much of the conversation
in the past year, and obviously four years, but I think
to the regular consumer,
the last year has been a significant shift in talking about and hearing about AI.
Everyone has in their mind
the idea that we are being surveilled for data.
And I think a new heightened awareness that maybe we didn't have before.
So now I'm seeing the comments about those two lawyers in the park like, well, you know what, cheating is not actually a crime.
And they should be able to live out their life
without fear of being filmed in public.
I think that commentary is a direct backlash
from the awareness that people now have about how heinous filming in public is
because of the commentary around the meta glasses.
And I think a lot of that attention came from Kylie Jenner.
So then if I talk about Emma Chamberlain and Emma Grade,
I would say that Emma Chamberlain's theory is definitely being exemplified
in this particular Kylie Jenner meta glasses example.
Emma's saying, influencing as we know it is dead
because the consumer is aware they're being sold to,
and they don't want to be sold to.
Or at least that it's less effective than it's ever been
to sell things through influencers
because everyone knows that they're watching an ad.
And they're not believing that the person who's pushing the products
that they're showing on their TikTok or Instagram actually cares about that product
and actually uses that product.
And then the Vulture article about Audrey Peters,
that she's rage baiting everybody by door dashing her three meals a day,
and that's not actually something that she does.
It's part of her strategy to stay relevant.
The veil of the relatability of influencers on TikTok,
which was a big reason why I think the platform took off
over Instagram for short form video
was that people felt Instagram influencers were canned and polished,
and TikTok influencers were relatable and real.
That relatability and realness was discovered to be sellable.
Once everything became an ad, it's no longer relatable anymore.
Okay, so the veil of influencing has fallen.
At the same time, Meta is trying to rely on that same influencing strategy
to push a technology that nobody is consenting to
and nobody seems to actually want.
I'm going to read you a couple of the headlines from Apple News
when I type in meta glasses into search.
New York says the cursed quest to make meta glasses cool
out of meta glasses could be the gateway into a queer dystopian nightmare.
Vox says meta glasses are killing the vibe.
That, plus their partnership with a bunch of the cool creative people
that I at least follow on Instagram shows me that they're still living in a maybe 5 years ago,
influencer brand strategy roll out
where they think that just by putting the product onto a cool person
will make the product sell more.
I'm sure it has raised their sale numbers to some degree,
but it has also, I think, inflated the scrutiny
and the criticism on the product
and the technology itself.
All that to say, I think one of the biggest social media giants in the game
is seemingly failing to understand what a creator like Emma Chamberlain
and even a creator like Audrey Peters might already understand.
A lot of times, rage will get you the views,
which is what Meta seems to want views, not rage.
But consumers may not be transacting and relating to ads content
on social media the way that they once did.
Even if it's Kylie Jenner promoting your product.