What art does:
an unfinished theory
Watch as I read/process
this tiny book here in 7 mins
I JUST DISCOVERED
I WAS JUST WANDERING
WHAT ART DOES
WHAT ART DOES AN UNFINISHED
THEORY
WHAT ART DOES AN UNFINISHED
THEORY BY BRIAN ENO AND
BETTE A.
I GOTTA READ YOU SOME
IT'S LOW KEY EXACTLY WHAT
I THOUGHT IT WAS GONNA
IT'S BLOWING MY MIND
SO WHAT
IS ART
THEY SAY IT COULD BE ANY
OF THESE THINGS
BUT THEN WHERE THEY'RE ALSO
TALKING ABOUT ALL OF THESE
THINGS
PAUSE TO READ THEY SAY NONE
OF THOSE THINGS ARE NECESSARY
BUT WE PUNCTUATE
OUR LIVES WITH THEM
WE DON'T HAVE TO DO THEM BUT
THEY GIVE LIFE MEANING
THEY SAY THE LESS FUNCTIONAL
A THING IS
THE MORE SPACE THERE IS
FUNCTION
ART
THEY SAY
THE LESS FUNCTIONAL A THING IS - THE LESS IT HAS TO DO
SOMETHING IN PARTICULAR - THE MORE SPACE FOR ART
THERE IS IN IT; THE MORE FREEDOM THERE IS IN IT.
WHOA!!
FUNCTION
ART
The art engagement begins where the functional
engagement ends.
THE ART ENGAGEMENT BEGINS
WHERE THE FUNCTIONAL ENGAGEMENT
OH MY GOD
SO GOOD
SOME THINGS THEY SAY
ARE PART ART PART
FUNCTION
LIKE IF YOU ARE RUNNING
FOR A BUS YOU CAN
YOU'VE TAKEN A FUNCTIONAL
THING THAT YOU NEED
AND YOU TURNED IT INTO ART
WHY DO WE SPEND OUR
time
on these
NON-FUNCTIONAL
ACTIVITIES WE CALL
ART?
Here's a simple idea:
WHY DO WE SPEND OUR TIME ON
THESE NON FUNCTIONAL
THAT WE CALL ART HERE IS A
SIMPLE IDEA
MAKING
FEELINGS
HAPPEN
ART IS A WAY OF MAKING FEELINGS HAPPEN
ART IS A WAY OF MAKING
FEELINGS HAPPEN
SORRY I MAY OR MAY NOT BE
READING THIS WHOLE THING OUT LOUD
FEELINGS HAVE A BAD REP THEY
SAY THEY
IMPORTANT
FEELINGS COME
BEFORE THOUGHT AND
ARTICULATION.
THEY ARE OUR ANTENNAE, THEY HELP US FEEL OUR WAY
FORWARD INTO THE FUTURE.
THEY HELP US FEEL OUR WAY
FORWARD INTO
THE FUTURE
MOST OF THE REALLY BIG
CHOICES IN OUR LIVES
THEY WRITE LIKE WHO TO MARRY
WHO TO VOTE FOR WHICH
JOB TO TAKE
WHETHER OR NOT TO TRY TO HAVE CHILDREN AREN'T BASED ON JUST THE
CAREFUL APPLICATION
OF LOGIC AND DEDUCTION
WE USE OUR FEELINGS FEELINGS
ARE SO POWERFUL BECAUSE
THEY AREN'T ARTICULATED
THESE ARE THE THINGS THAT WE
JUST INTUITIVELY
AND IT'S WHY MARKETERS
CAPITALIZE ON THEM RIGHT
BECAUSE THEY KNOW HOW
POWERFUL THEY ARE
ART IS HARMLESS BECAUSE
ART IS A
FICTION
ART IS ESCAPABLE
ART
ART IS ESCAPABLE
THAT'S SO INTERESTING
WE CAN EXPERIENCE THE HEARTBREAK OF A CHARACTER IN A MOVIE
BUT AT A SAFE DISTANCE
IT'S A WAY TO ACCESS THE
BREADTH OF HUMAN EXPERIENCE
SAFELY
ART CAN HAVE A TREMENDOUS EFFECT ON THE WORLD - THAT IS
WHY DICTATORS HAVE BEEN SO EAGER TO LOCK ARTISTS AWAY
OR EMPLOY THEM AS PROPAGANDISTS.
but art is effective
because
it is
SAFE
THAT IS WHY
THAT IS WHY DICTATORS HAVE
BEEN SO EAGER TO LOCK ARTISTS AWAY
OR EMPLOY THEM AS PROPAGANDISTS
YOU CAN READ A NOVEL AND EXPERIENCE THE HORROR OF A
PRISON OR THE BEAUTY OF DEEP LOVE - BUT YOU DON'T HAVE
TO ENDURE THE REAL-WORLD CONSEQUENCES OF THOSE THINGS.
YOU CAN SHUT THE BOOK. YOU CAN LEAVE THE GALLERY. YOU CAN
STOP DANCING, CLOSE YOUR EYES, EXIT THE MOVIE THEATRE.
YOU CAN GO AWAY AND YOU CAN GET BACK TO YOUR LIFE.
BUT YOU CAN TAKE WITH YOU SOME MEMORY OF THE FEELINGS
YOU HAD AND THAT CAN CHANGE YOU.
THE MEMORIES
OF THE FEELINGS
CAN CHANGE YOU
AND THAT CAN CHANGE YOU SO
THESE FICTIONAL FEELINGS
THESE FEELINGS THAT WE GET
FROM ART THAT ARE NOT
NECESSARILY
OR RATHER THAT WE HAVEN'T
EXPERIENCED OURSELVES
MAYBE THEY WRITE THAT THEY
ENRICH YOUR FEELINGS
THEY TELL YOU SOMETHING
ABOUT OTHER POSSIBLE
WORLDS THOSE YOU MIGHT WANT TO BE IN
AND THOSE YOU MIGHT WANT TO
AVOID
SO WE CARRY THESE FICTIONAL
WORLDS WITH US ALL THE TIME
THEY WRITE AND THEY SAY THAT
LIKE 1984 OR OTHER WORKS
WHERE THEY ARE LITERALLY
CREATING THESE
IT'S VERY EASY TO SEE THEM AS A COMPLETE
WORLD
IT'S HARDER TO SEE HOW
SOMETHING SO SMALL AS AN
EARING DOES THAT
HOW IS ANOTHER WORLD
SUGGESTED WHEN THERE IS NO
NARRATIVE OR EXPLANATION INVOLVED? WHERE DO WE FIND
THAT MESSAGE IN A SMALL OBJECT? HOW DOES THAT WORK?
Let's start explaining this by asking: what makes
you choose one earring over another? You've seen
earrings all your life, so when you see a new one, you
immediately unconsciously compare it to all the others
you've seen. In your history of earring-viewing, how
does this one compare?
WHAT MAKES YOU CHOOSE ONE
EARING OVER ANOTHER
YOU'VE SEEN
SO WHEN YOU SEE A NEW ONE,
YOU IMMEDIATELY
UNCONSCIOUSLY
COMPARE IT TO ALL THE OTHERS
YOU'VE SEEN
ART IS FRAGMENTS
OF FICTIONAL
WORLDS
To understand why art
is an important human activity.
play
let's look at
and how
that works for children.
TO UNDERSTAND WHY ART
IS AN IMPORTANT HUMAN ACTIVITY.
LET'S LOOK AT PLAY AND HOW
THAT WORKS FOR CHILDREN
All young animals
want to play
and
humans
more than most
Children don't have to be
encouraged to play. They love
doing it. We see them jumping and
running and competing and developing
their bodies, taking things apart and
broadening their knowledge of the world.
ALL YOUNG ANIMALS
AND HUMANS MORE THAN MOST
THE PLEASURE OF PLAY EVOLVED
TO KEEP US PLAYING!
SO THEY WRITE WHAT DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH ART
HERE'S A PROPOSAL ART
IS HOW ADULTS PLAY
PLAY IS RESEARCH
WE RESEARCH OUR FEELINGS
WOW WOW WOW
What
is it that
I really
like
?
The musician Jon Hassell
used to say that this is
the most important question
you can ask yourself.
WHAT IS IT THAT I REALLY LIKE TO
DISCOVER
WHAT YOU REALLY LIKE IS TO HAVE A GUIDING
STAR AND TO BE ABLE TO NAVIGATE THROUGH THE
BLIZZARD OF ALL THE
TELLING YOU WHAT YOU OUGHT
TO LIKE
IT IS YOUR CLAIM
YOUR CLAIM TO
INDEPENDENCE OF
MIND
THROUGH ART YOU CAN
INVESTIGATE THE KIND OF
FEELINGS AND WHERE TO GET THEM
AND IT MAKES THE CASE HONESTLY
FOR WHY ART
FOR WHY ART IS ALL THE MORE
PRESSING AND IMPORTANT
AS WE EXPERIENCE
THIS BARRAGE
OF KIND OF ALGORITHMIC
FLATTENING
TO BE ABLE TO IDENTIFY THINGS
THAT YOU GENUINELY
OUTSIDE OF ANYONE ELSE
THAT YOU GENUINELY LOVE OR
FIND PLEASURE IN
OR THAT EVOKE SOMETHING
AS THEY SAY YOUR CLAIM TO
INDEPENDENCE OF MIND
IT'S AN EXTREMELY
POWERFUL
TOOL
What an artist chooses to write or
make drawings or songs about,
can draw our attention to certain
worlds. It tells us that somebody
takes something seriously, perhaps
finds it beautiful or threatening,
and invites us to rethink how we
feel about it.
The things we care about are the things we make
art about. We frame them with our attention.
Art is proof of care.
IT'S AN EXTREMELY POWERFUL
TOOL
THE THINGS WE CARE ABOUT ARE
THE THINGS WE
ART ABOUT. WE FRAME THEM WITH OUR
ATTENTION.
ART IS PROOF OF CARE.
ART IS PROOF OF CARE
ART IS SHOWING US WHAT IS
WRONG OR FUN ABOUT
THE WORLD WE INHABIT
CERTAIN FORMS OF ART GET
CRITICIZED FOR BEING ESCAPIST
THERE'S AN ASSUMPTION THAT
GOOD ART MUST ALWAYS BE
IN SOME WAY WHAT'S WRONG
WITH WANTING TO EXPERIENCE
THAT IS BETTER
WHAT DOES THAT TELL YOU
ABOUT THIS ONE
ART CAN FORM A CONTRAST
A CONTRAST TO THE WORLD YOU'RE
IN AND YOU FIND YOURSELF
WHAT IS IT
WHAT IS IT ABOUT THIS OTHER
WORLD THAT I LIKE THAT ISN'T
IN MY WORLD
For the writer bell
hooks, art exists to
consider what is
possible - how else
things could be - not
just what is.
ART EXISTS TO CONSIDER WHAT IS
POSSIBLE - HOW ELSE
THINGS COULD BE - NOT
JUST WHAT IS.
HOW ELSE THINGS COULD BE NOT
JUST WHAT IS.
WRITE ABOUT HOW HUMANS
ARE MORE DIFFERENT THAN WE'VE EVER BEEN BEFORE
USED TO BE GENERALISTS
WHERE EVERYONE IN THE SAME
AREA DID PRETTY MUCH THE SAME
HAD THE SAME SKILLS BUT NOW WE
THE BENEFICIARIES OF THOUSANDS OF
NOT JUST THE ONE WE CARRY
INSIDE OUR SKULL
HOW DO ALL THESE WILDLY
DIFFERENT BRAINS STAY
CONNECTED
WHAT CAN HOLD US TOGETHER
SO THAT THE WHOLE SYSTEM
STILL HAS SOME
UNITY
SO THAT WE CAN DO ALL THESE
COMPLICATED THINGS
TOGETHER
BECAUSE
SYSTEMS RELY ON ALL OF THESE
DIFFERENT PIECES WORKING
TOGETHER
RIGHT THEY WRITE
ART IS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT BINDS PEOPLE TOGETHER
ART IS A RESERVOIR OF SHARED
EXPERIENCES
THAT GIVES US WAYS
OF COMPLEX FEELINGS AND
IDENTITIES
IT IS THE LANGUAGE THROUGH
WHICH ALL OF OUR DIFFERENT
BRAINS AND EXPERIENCES AND IDENTITIES CAN
COMMUNICATE
THE CIRCULATORY SYSTEM OF
COMMUNITY CIVILIZATION
IS SHARED IMAGINATION
WE SHIFT SOCIETIES WE SHIFT
IDEOLOGIES
WAYS OF BEING AND ACTING BY
MODELING
LIKE THEY USE THE EXAMPLE HERE
OF IN THE WESTERN WORLD
GENDER IDENTITY IS BECOMING
MORE FLUID
PROBABLY NOT BECAUSE
OF LEGISLATION
IN FACT DEFINITELY NOT BECAUSE OF
ONE OF THE PRIMARY WAYS WE BECOME
WITH THAT SORT OF
IS
MODELING IT OR SEEING IT BEING
MODELED IN ART
BUT BECAUSE ART IS FICTIONAL
WE HAVE SOME DISTANCE
THERE ARE NO REAL WORLD
CONSEQUENCES TO
THOSE THOUGHTS
SO PEOPLE ENGAGE IN
COMMUNAL SOCIAL SETTINGS
AS A WAY TO PUSH
THEIR THINKING FORWARD
BEING
together in art
is an
agreement
to share some
feelings
with each other
That involves being
vulnerable together,
opening up to each other.
Art can be a way that
people who might be wildly
different in many aspects
can share something.
At the level of feelings we
can be equals.
We all have them.
IN ART IS AN AGREEMENT TO
SHARE SOME FEELINGS WITH
EACH OTHER
THE CLIMATE CRISIS THE WARS
THE INCREASING INEQUALITY
THE WORLD URGENTLY NEEDS
NEW WAYS OF UNDERSTANDING
AND WHERE WE COULD GO
ART IS ONE OF THE WAYS WE
HELPING US FEEL NEW FUTURES
AND UNDERSTANDING THE POWERS OF COMMUNITY
TO BRING ABOUT THE CHANGES
WE NEED
SCIENCE MAKES MODELS OF
THINGS SO WE CAN UNDERSTAND
HOW THEY WORK
ART MAKES MODELS OF THINGS
SO WE CAN UNDERSTAND HOW
WE WORK