Hook
More breakout videos from this creator.
So the Philadelphia in your fridge costs $4.49 for 8 ounces. Today, I'm going to teach you how to make the same amount for about a dollar with milk and lemon. I've made this every Sunday with my dad for three months now and I am never going back. And later, I will show you the 10 second blend that makes it taste like the store tub plus the salty leftover liquid that bakes into bakery level bread. Pour four cups of whole milk into a heavy pot and turn the burner to medium. That is step one and you are already halfway done. Whole milk from Walmart. Great Value is $3.68 a gallon in September 2026. So those four cups cost you 92 cents. Add a quarter teaspoon of salt later, tablespoon of lemon juice now and you are at about $1.05 total for 8 ounces. Philadelphia. Original 8 ounce brick is $4.49 at Target, $4.79 at most grocery chains. Same quantity, one quarter of the price. No bar gum, no locust bean gum, no natamycin preservative. Watch what happens as that pot warms. Milk looks smooth, but it is really thousands of tiny protein bundles called casein micelles floating in water. Think of them like little wool balls with a negative charge that makes them repel each other. Heat loosens them. Acid cancels the charge. When both hit together, the balls grab each other and squeeze out water. That is curd and whey. Cheese is not manufactured, it is milk falling apart on purpose. Stir slowly while it heats and keep a thermometer in there if you have one. You want 185 degrees Fahrenheit, just steaming with tiny bubbles around the edge, never a rolling boil. Boiling makes rubbery curds. If you do not have a thermometer, wait till it steams hard and the surface shivers. That takes about 8 to 10 minutes on most stoves. Now squeeze in two tablespoons of fresh lemon juice or plain white vinegar. Store brand lemon juice is $2.48 for a 32 ounce bottle at Walmart. So those two tablespoons cost 7 cents. Stir once slowly, one full circle, then stop and turn the heat off. Leave it alone for 10 minutes, do not keep stirring. I know it looks like sweet soupy milk. Give it those 10 minutes, when you come back, it will look completely different. White clouds floating in thin yellowish liquid. That yellow liquid is whey, the white clouds are your cream cheese. That separation is the whole recipe. William Lawrence figured out the commercial version of this in Chester, New York in 1872. He was trying to copy a French cheese called Neufchatel, added extra cream to the curd and called it Philadelphia, because Philadelphia had a reputation for top quality dairy in the 1800s. Kraft Heinz still makes it there today with milk, cream, salt, guar and carob gum and natamycin to stop mold. Line a strainer with cheesecloth and set it over a big bowl. Amazon sells a three pack of unbleached cotton cheesecloth for $5.99 and one sheet lasts for dozens of batches if you rinse it. No cheesecloth in the house? A clean cotton pillowcase works, a paper coffee filter works, it just drains slower. Pour the whole pot in gently. Save every drop of that whey in the bowl. Looks like dishwater. It tastes lightly salty and lemony and it is pure protein and minerals. Let it drain 30 minutes for soft spreadable tub style, 60 to 90 minutes for firm brick style. Time is texture. Half an hour leaves more moisture for bagels, an hour and a half squeezes out more whey for slicing and cheesecake. I drain mine 45 minutes because I like it to hold a peak but still spread without tearing toast. Scoop that warm drained curd into a blender or food processor, add a pinch of salt, about 1/8 of a teaspoon and one tablespoon of the whey back in. Blend 10 seconds, stop, scrape, blend 10 seconds again. That second blend is the Philadelphia trick. Factory blades shear the curd until the fat re-emulsifies completely smooth. Your home blender does the same thing. If it looks crumbly, add whey half a teaspoon at a time. If it looks runny, you added too much. You cannot fix runny except by draining again, so go slow. Taste it warm, it should taste clean, milky, faintly tangy, lightly salty. Chill it two hours in a sealed container and the flavor deepens. Cold firms the butterfat and rounds off the lemon edge. That is why store tubs taste milder the next day too. A four cup batch makes almost exactly 8 ounces, one full cup. It keeps 7 to 10 days in the fridge at 38 degrees. Use pasteurized whole milk, not raw and wash the pot, strainer and jar with hot soapy water. Acid plus heat kills most. Things, cold storage handles the rest. If you are getting value here, hit subscribe. I put the extended flavor math and members only test batches up for channel members every month. Things like smoked salmon spread, cost breakdowns and three store clones side by side. That salty whey you saved is where the second payoff lives. Do not pour it down the sink. One batch gives you about three cups. Use one cup in place of water in pancake mix, bread dough, pizza dough or mashed potatoes. The protein browns faster and the crumb stays soft for days. My sandwich loaf with one cup whey instead of water tastes like a $6 bakery loaf. Freeze the rest in ice cube trays. Each cube is two tablespoons. Perfect to drop into smoothies or soup for extra protein without powder. I only kill four myths because the label makes this seem complicated and it is not. Myth one, you need heavy cream. You do not. Philadelphia adds cream to raise fat to about 33%. Whole milk is 3.25% fat, but once you drain off three cups of watery whey, the solids left behind concentrate to about 30 to 32% fat. Same richness, no $4 pint of cream needed. If you want extra decadent, replace one cup of milk with one cup of half and half. Cost goes up 60 cents, fat goes up about 4 points, totally optional. Myth two, you need rennet or live cultures. Hard cheeses need rennet to lock protein tightly for aging. Fresh acid cheese does not. Lemon juice drops pH to about 4.6, the exact point casein loses its charge and clumps. Vinegar does the same. Bottled lemon, fresh lemon, white distilled vinegar at $3.28 a gallon all work identically. Pickles do not need a lab, neither does this. Myth three, the store tub is fresher, purer. Flip a Philadelphia tub over, milk, cream, salt plus carob gum, guar gum, natamycin. Those gums hold water so the tub stays firm for 90 days in a truck and on a shelf. Your version holds for 10 days because it has no gums, that is fresher by definition. The slight grain you sometimes get in homemade is just under-blended curd. Blend longer, add a touch more whey, it goes away. Myth four, any milk works, skim fails. Ultra-pasteurized often fails. Skim has no fat to give it body, so you get ricotta dust and water. Ultra-pasteurized milk is heated to 280 degrees at the plant which pre-scrambles the proteins so they cannot clump cleanly by regular pasteurized whole milk in a jug. Great Value, Kirkland, Dean, any regional dairy. Check the label. Yeah, if it says ultra-pasteurized, put it back for cereal and grab the regular jug for cheese. Your lawn cannot read the logo applies to bagels too. Your bagel cannot read Philadelphia. Where to buy this without overthinking it? Milk, any grocery store, $3.50 to $4.20 a gallon for store brand in most states. Lemon juice, Realemon 32 ounce $2.48 at Walmart, lasts 25 batches. Cheesecloth, Amazon high wear unbleached three pack $5.99 or Walmart Mainstays two pack $4.12 in the canning aisle. Fine mesh strainer, $8.97. Mainstays 8 inch, you already own one for pasta. Thermometer optional, ThermoPro instant read $12.99 on Amazon. Nice, but not required. Total startup, if you own nothing, is under $15. And after that, each batch is about a dollar. Three fast variations once you nail plain. Garlic herb that copies the $6.29 Philadelphia garden vegetable tub. Mince one small garlic clove very fine, chop a tablespoon of fresh dill or chives, stir into one finished cup with an extra pinch of salt. Cost adds 18 cents, tastes stronger than store because the herbs are fresh, not dried dust. Whipped tub style, add two extra tablespoons whey before the final blend and whip 30 seconds longer. You fold in air and water, volume jumps about 20%, spreads like soft butter. Use within five days because extra moisture shortens life by a couple days. Dense New York cheesecake base, drain 90 minutes until crumbly dry, blend with two tablespoons sugar per cup and one egg yolk when baking. Bakery cheesecake uses extra gum to survive freezing. Yours, baked fresh, needs none of it. One 8 ounce homemade batch plus half a cup sugar plus two eggs plus a graham crust makes a 7 inch cake that slices clean after chilling overnight. Math for a year, because this is where it stops being a fun experiment. One tub a week at $4.49 is $233.48 a year. One homemade batch a week at $1.05 is $54.60 a year. You save $178.88. Two tubs a week for a family that packs lunches, store cost $466.96, homemade $109.20. You save $357.76. Even if milk jumps to $5 a gallon, your per batch cost is $1.32, yearly $68.64, still $165 cheaper. The pot, stove and 15 minutes hands on time do not change. If that saves you $180 this year and helps you make the most delicious cream cheese ever, share it with someone still buying three tubs every month. See you in the next.