HOW ON EARTH
DETECT PAPER MILL
OR FRAUDULENT RESEARCH
REVIEW PROCESS?
IN SOME OF
QUESTIONS I GOT
ABOUT ACADEMIC PAPER
MILLS.
IS JESS.
MEDIA PROFESSOR,
RESEARCHER AND TEACHER
OF GEORGIA,
FOUNDING EDITOR AND
NEW SPRINGER NATURE
CREATOR AND INFLUENCER
STUDIES.
THE SECOND QUESTION I GOT
WAS THE CRIME
SYNDICATE ANGLE OF
SAID, WELL,
HERE? AND THE
CRIME HERE IS
THAT SOMETIMES,
BUT NOT ALWAYS,
BUT SOMETIMES PAPER
MILLS ARE ATTACHED
ORGANISED CRIME GROUPS.
degruyterbrill.com
THE SECOND QUESTION
IS A PROBLEM IS
THIS, ACTUALLY?
AND ACCORDING TO
DE GRUYTER BRILL,
GERMAN SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING
HOUSE,
UH, OUT OF
THE 44,000 ARTICLES
RETRACTED IN THE
LAST COUPLE OF YEARS
FROM ACADEMIC JOURNALS,
AROUND 7,000 OF
THOSE WERE ATTRIBUTED
TO PAPER MILLS.
AND THEY GO
OUT THAT AROUND
400,000 ARTICLES
PRODUCED BY ACADEMIC
HAVE INFILTRATED SCIENTIFIC
LAST TWO DECADES.
OF COURSE,
DO YOU SPOT
IS, AND FULL
EVERYTHING I'M ABOUT
TO SAY IS
AUTOMATIC SIGN SOMETHING
PAPER MILL,
OF THE PROBLEM.
SO SOME PUBLICATION
ETHICS ADVISE PEOPLE
TO FIRST GO
SECTION
DETERMINE IF SOMETHING
IS PAPER MILL
FIRST AND FOREMOST,
THESE REFERENCE SECTIONS
MIGHT BE PADDED,
THAT THERE MAY
BE A TON
OF SELF CITATIONS.
OR THERE ARE
CITATIONS TO ARTICLES
THAT DON'T QUITE
BUT A LOT
OF THEM. THIS
SIGN SOMEONE HAS
PAID TO INCLUDE
SOMETHING IN A
REFERENCE LIST.
BE A SIGN
THAT PROBLEMATIC PAPERS
FROM PAPER MILLS
OFTEN CITE OTHER
PAPER MILLS.
Ozturk. Or the citations could be fake – a
consequence of fabricated responses, known
as hallucinations, from large language models
or attempts to evade plagiarism detectors.
Ozturk recalls seeing the phrase '1 others'
tacked onto the end of an author list in one
citation, possibly an AI approximation of the
Latin et al. that is often used to shorten
author lists.
THIS DAY AND
HALLUCINATED CITATIONS,
BY LARGE LANGUAGE
CAN BE ASSIGNED
SOMETHING AS PAPER
MILL RESEARCH.
IS ONE SUCH
IT HAPPENING.
PAUSE TO READ.
CHECK TO SEE
FROM A PAPER
AUTHOR AFFILIATIONS.
IN THIS DAY AND AGE
HAS AN ORCHID
RESEARCHER AND CONTRIBUTOR.
IDI.
TEACH MY RESEARCH
METHOD STUDENTS THAT
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS
FOR RESEARCHERS.
YOU ARE WHO
ARE AND YOU'VE
DONE.
CANNOT PROVIDE AN
ORCHID,
A SIGN OF
RESEARCHER.
ADDITIONALLY, IS IF
A CO AUTHORED
PAPER,
FIND ANY EVIDENCE
THESE AUTHORS HAVE
PUBLISHED ANYWHERE ELSE
IT COULD BE
A PAPER MILL
RESEARCH.
ANOTHER THING IS
TO THE METHODOLOGY.
PAPER MILL RESEARCH
IS VERY FORMULAIC
AND BORING AND
DRAWS ON EXISTING
PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATA
SETS TO MAKE
VERY BASIC,
RATHER NOT IMPRESSIVE
SO WHILE THIS
RESEARCH MAY BE
TECHNICALLY LEGITIMATE,
ADVANCE THE FIELD
IN A SUBSTANTIAL
THAT IS NECESSARY
FOR TOP QUARTILE
ACADEMIC JOURNALS. FINALLY,
IRREGULARITIES IN THE
CAN BE
ANOTHER BIG PREDICTOR.
SOME PUBLICATION ETHICS
SAY THAT ABSTRACTS
AND LONG
AND SCATTERED AND
A SIGN OF
ARTICLES.
indicate that AI-
generated text was just copied straight into
the manuscript. Using AI tools to prepare or
refine a manuscript is not necessarily
unethical, but most journals ask that this is
disclosed; otherwise, it could hint that the
technology was used inappropriately in other
parts of the paper.
Another signature of iffy papers is the use of
'tortured phrases' – bizarre expressions that
result from replacing each word in an
established scientific term with synonyms,
probably to avoid plagiarism detectors. Some
notable examples include 'bosom peril' in
place of breast cancer and 'underground
creepy crawly state' instead of ant colony.
Tortured phrases are just one such signature
identified by the Problematic Paper Screener,
a free online tool that automatically checks
papers for signs of fraud, such as suspicious
phrases and citations to retracted papers.
AND THEN THIS
MY FAVOURITES
OF IN MY
USE OF TORTURED
PHRASES AS
MILL RESEARCH.
THIS IS, AS
BIZARRE EXPRESSIONS THAT
RESULT FROM REPLACING
EACH WORD IN AN
SCIENTIFIC TERM WITH
SYNONYMS
TO AVOID PLAGIARISM
DETECTORS AND BOSOM
MAKES ME LAUGH
EVERY TIME.
conduct.
As Seifert writes:
All the above points show that the
"success" of paper mills does not rely on
a single tactic but a well-balanced
portfolio of malicious strategies.
These strategies complement each
other to lead to the desired result. At
the same time, the portfolio of
strategies minimizes the risk of the
fraud authors to be identified,
minimizing the risk of negative
professional consequences.
RETRACTION WATCH POINTS
THAT IT'S NOT
YOU KNOW
A PAPER MILL
IT IS A
NOT A SINGLE
BUT A WELL
BALANCED PORTFOLIO OF
MALICIOUS STRATEGIES.
SO TO THE
COMMENTS WHO ARE
JUST LIKE, OH,
PAYING ENOUGH ATTENTION
OR THE NUMBERS
OF THE METHOD,
WOW.
COMING UP WITH
YOU KNOW
nobody else did.
WHAT OTHER QUESTIONS
HAVE DOWN BELOW.