yesterday I posted
how Stanford University
uncovered that you
as a relate
to this hiring market
and that algorithmic
monoculture is
causing candidates to
be systematically rejected
across industries based
and applicant-tracking
systems that are
being used at scale.
The recruiters and
my comment section
are not happy.
So let's break
I think is
shaking the nest
transparent for everyone,
candidates included. Hi,
my name is Beverly Dines. I'm
a chief operating officer.
I've been scaling operations
for over a
ton of different
I have built
recruitment teams from
I have managed
ATS implementation,
and I have seen
end scoring measures
firsthand.
So let's get into it.
The first response I keep
saying is that
"This is a conspiracy"
conspiracy
that we are
not auto-rejecting candidates.
I have to be really honest.
As somebody also
unemployed and had
to have navigated
so I've seen
both sides to
this response is
gaslighting at its
finest.
I have thousands
upon thousands of
comments from job
seekers
exact same experience.
A 2:00 AM rejection
email after having just
submitted the application.
Getting a rejection
email seconds after
submitting it.
So you really mean to tell me that your
recruiters are lying
sitting down, waiting
by the computer,
doing is clicking
the rejection prompt
waiting for somebody
any given time
of the day.
No applicant tracking
systems have auto
rejection categorizations built
in.
These are just
some examples. But I took it a step further because
tired of seeing
this comment in my comment sections.
I went into
my own LinkedIn
business account,
created a fake
job posting.
Of course, because
that here.
The screenshot that
literally proves that.
If I wanted
that would auto
reject candidates.
It would immediately
auto-reject the
candidate if they didn't meet
the criteria I'm looking for
before I had
ever had a chance to look
at their resume.
This is not
a conspiracy. It's
quite literally how
the product works
and the candidates
that are experiencing
this at scale
are not imagining
it.
"ATS aren't Auto-Rejecting"
The second response I
receive is ATS
rejecting candidates,
they're just organizing
them. This is arguing
semantics.
The moment that
for accountability,
overwhelmed recruiters and
overwhelmed HR leader,
going to go
back and manually
review all of
the applicants that the ATS has said are
not a fit.
So it does not matter if the machine is
sending the rejection email
or if the recruiter is? The
candidate has been
auto categorized
and thus eliminated
from the running
as a result
of the auto
categorization.
That is an
auto rejection.
The mechanism does
not change the
outcome to the
other side of
we need to
reinvest in putting
in human resources.
Organizations need to
hire more recruiters,
hire more HR
leaders. The community
what they're experiencing.
And if you're
watching this,
use this as an opportunity
in and listen to
the discourse that's
in the comment section.
Comment below if this resonated with you
and follow for more
because this conversation
is not over.