Hook
More breakout videos from this creator.
People react to AI in art the same way they react to a cockroach landing in their drink. Whoa. Tell me more. So this is a real finding from economists at the University of Chicago who published last month a paper called Art and the Machine, Why People Devalue AI-Generated Creative Work? And they ran auctions with real money. They told people that a painting was 99% made by a human artist, an AI tool just filled in a tiny section. That 1% wiped out 16% of the artwork's value. But this is interesting, when they ran this the other way around, going from 25% AI to 50% AI, it barely moved the needle. The damage was always at the boundary between the human and the machine at the moment that any AI was involved. So the mechanism is that the researchers recognise this pattern, it's called contamination psychology. The same thing happens when a sterilised cockroach touches someone's juice. Nothing changed about the juice but you're not drinking it because it's not clean juice. It crossed a line into something that's a different category of thing. That's what a trace of AI does to a painting in an auction, it re-categorizes it into something else. We just don't know how extreme yet this "gross/okay" dichotomy is that we see in art. We don't know how it transfers. So don't get me wrong, it doesn't mean that using AI is bad, but it does say that we've got a long way to go before we really understand what it takes to use it with others, for things that genuinely require effortful, authentic human work. I'm Helen from Artificiality. Follow me for more on what it means to be human with AI.