Original caption
Can we please talk about Social Security without pretending this is some mysterious financial catastrophe that descended from the heavens? Because Congress has choices. Right now, Social Security’s retirement trust fund is projected to be unable to pay 100% of scheduled benefits beginning in late 2032 unless Congress acts. That does NOT mean Social Security “goes bankrupt.” It does NOT mean benefits become zero. It means incoming revenue would no longer be enough to pay every dollar of currently scheduled benefits—and absent legislation, retirees would face an enormous automatic reduction. Current estimates put it around 22%. Twenty-two percent. Imagine telling somebody who worked for 40 or 50 years: Hey, remember that retirement program you paid into with every paycheck? We’re going to need about one-fifth of that back. Meanwhile, there’s another number Americans should know. In 2026, Social Security payroll taxes apply only to the first $184,500 of wages. After that? The Social Security portion of the payroll tax stops. Which produces one of the strangest sentences in American tax policy: A worker earning $184,500 can hit the same maximum employee Social Security payroll tax as someone earning millions in wages. Bernie Sanders has proposed a rather radical solution. Brace yourselves. Make very wealthy people contribute Social Security taxes on more of their income. I know. Someone fetch the smelling salts. 😂 His Social Security Expansion Act would subject income above $250,000 to additional Social Security taxation, tax certain investment income, increase benefits by $2,400 a year, and—according to Social Security Administration analysis of the proposal—extend the program’s solvency for approximately 75 years. And more than 91% of American households wouldn’t pay another penny in taxes under the proposal, according to the bill’s sponsors. So when somebody tells you: “We have no choice. Social Security benefits have to be cut.” Stop them right there. Because that’s not an economic fact. That’s a policy preference. Congress could raise the retirement age. Congress could reduce benefits. Congress could change the benefit formula. Congress could raise revenue. Congress could ask high earners to contribute more. Those are political choices. And personally, before we tell the 72-year-old retired cashier living on $1,800 a month that America simply cannot afford her Social Security check anymore… I’d like to exhaust the “maybe the millionaire could keep paying Social Security tax after February” option first. Call me crazy. Social Security isn’t charity. Workers finance it throughout their careers. The question isn’t whether America has options to preserve it. We do. The question is who Congress decides should pay the price. And THAT is the debate every American should be paying attention to before 2032 arrives. #SocialSecurity #BernieSanders #Retirement #EconomicJustice #WorkingClass