We tested 30 ice cream sandwiches to find these standouts

We tested 30 ice cream sandwiches to find these standouts The best all-around classic The 365 by Whole Foods Market ice cream sandwich uses ice cream specifically made with egg yolks, resulting in a custard-like texture. It was also the only old-school-style sandwich we tested that had equally delicious ice cream and wafers. The best chocolate chip cookie sandwich Trader Joe's Sublime ice cream sandwiches are an elevated version of a nostalgic favorite. Soft chocolate-chip cookies with notes of molasses and brown sugar, premium egg-based ice cream, and an explosion of dark chocolate chips. A chocolate lover's dream Jeni's Chocolate Silk Pie ice cream sandwiches are for true chocolate fanatics. At first glance, the dark, dense cookies and whipped-looking ice cream make it clear you're about to plunge headfirst into the choco-verse. A dairy-free delight for coconut lovers With a smooth, dense texture and tender cookies, dairy-free So Delicious Vanilla Bean sandwiches were a favorite among vegan and non-vegan testers alike. But we must warn you: If you don't like coconut, you will not like this treat. A buttery cookie sandwich, sans the chippy rim If you don't love a chocolate-chip-encrusted perimeter, Target's Favorite Day Chocolate Chunk Cookie ice cream sandwich has you covered. All of our testers also loved the buttery, golden-brown cookies, stuffed with custard vanilla ice cream and a fudgy center. A tart, citrusy surprise Jeni's Key Lime Pie ice cream sandwiches were an unexpected hit with our panel. Tart key lime ice cream is bolstered by buttermilk and yogurt for a multidimensional acidity. The buttery, Teddy Graham-like cookies provide an excellent foil to the filling's zest. The best cookies-and-cream combo The 365 by Whole Foods Market Cookies & Cream ice cream sandwiches pack custardy ice cream with tons of tiny cookie pieces between brownie-like cookies with a rich, bittersweet cocoa punch. "The cookie steals the show," said one taster. The best budget sandwich Sweet and airy, Target's Favorite Day Vanilla-Flavored ice cream sandwiches are a classic treat — with an old-school price to match.